Zika conspiracy theories on social media putting vulnerable people at risk

Amsterdam, May 24, 2016 – Conspiracy theories and pseudoscientific claims refuting the facts around Zika virus vaccines could be putting vulnerable people at risk, according to a new study published in Vaccine. By analyzing social media in real time, researchers were able to identify conversations about Zika virus vaccines and pinpoint the conspiracy theories being discussed.

The researchers behind the study, from George Washington University, Johns Hopkins University and the University of Georgia in the US, say health authorities could make use of their real-time social media monitoring method to keep track of and respond to conspiracy theories that could harm public health.

Zika virus is found in Asia, Africa and South America, with Brazil and neighboring countries seeing a significant rise in cases in recent months. Spread by mosquitos and through sexual intercourse, Zika virus has also been linked to babies being born with small heads and brains — a condition called microcephaly.

There is still uncertainty around the origin and effects of Zika virus. Because of this, it has been subject to many conspiracy theories and pseudo-scientific claims. These claims, while lacking authority and easily disproven, can have a lasting effect on people’s health-related decisions.

One such pseudoscientific claim was that microcephaly is caused by the MMR vaccine and pharmaceutical companies are blaming Zika virus in order to profit from selling Zika vaccines. If people who are concerned and searching for information about Zika come across this story, they may be led to avoid vaccination and distrust health authorities.

“Once people have made up their minds about something it’s hard for them to change their opinions,” said lead author Prof. Mark Dredze from Johns Hopkins University. “I’d find it surprising if this sort of story really had no impact whatsoever, and I can’t imagine it would make people more likely to pursue a healthy response.”

To investigate the impact of the claims, the team monitored Twitter in real-time, which meant they could identify conversations as soon as they happened. The method gave them a fast insight into what people were talking about online. They identified nearly 140,000 Tweets between 1 January and 29 April 2016 that contained the keywords “vaccine” and “Zika.” They observed a number of conspiracy theories, or pseudoscientific claims, questioning why governments wanted a vaccine.

“Even though the science is relatively clear, we found many conspiracy theories that could be affecting people’s health-related decisions, such as whether to vaccinate,” said corresponding author Prof. David Broniatowski from George Washington University. “Unfortunately, the people most affected are from the most vulnerable communities, with little access to the facts.”

The researchers say public health authorities must address people’s concerns and debunk unscientific claims if they are to ensure a vaccine is effective. One way to do this, they say, is using their method of tracking conversations on social media. The method cuts the time it takes between the researcher wondering what people are talking about and them finding out, potentially making it much faster for a public health response to be mounted.

“Shortly after Zika rose to prominence, we were able to track these conversations very quickly using our social media monitoring method,” said Prof. Broniatowski. “This is a promising approach to the fast response to disease, and could help counteract the negative impact of these conspiracy theories in future.”


Read more on Elsevier Connect.

Notes for Editors

The article is: “Zika Vaccine Misconceptions: A social media analysis” by Mark Dredze, David Andre Broniatowski and Karen M Hilyard (doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2016.05.008). It appears in Vaccine (May 2016), published by Elsevier.

Copies of the paper are available to credentialed journalists upon request, contact Elsevier’s Newsroom at [email protected] or 31-20-485-2492.

About Vaccine

The official journal of The Edward Jenner Society and The Japanese Society for Vaccinology, Vaccine is the pre-eminent journal for those interested in vaccines and vaccination. The journal covers a wide range of vaccine-related topics, including human and veterinary vaccines for infectious and non-infectious diseases, production and manufacturing, and regulatory, societal and legislation aspects.

About Elsevier

Elsevier is a world-leading provider of information solutions that enhance the performance of science, health, and technology professionals, empowering them to make better decisions, deliver better care, and sometimes make groundbreaking discoveries that advance the boundaries of knowledge and human progress. Elsevier provides web-based, digital solutions — among them ScienceDirect, Scopus, Elsevier Research Intelligence and ClinicalKey — and publishes over 2,500 journals, including The Lancet and Cell, and more than 33,000 book titles, including a number of iconic reference works. Elsevier is part of RELX Group, a world-leading provider of information and analytics for professional and business customers across industries. http://www.elsevier.com

Media contact

Matthanja Muller
[email protected]

Media Contact

Matthanja Muller
[email protected]


UBC study raises the standard for measuring nerve cell death

Researchers at UBC's Okanagan campus have developed a new and improved method to judge the effectiveness of experimental therapies for neurodegeneration–the progressive loss of...

Pain in the neck

For millions of sufferers, there is nothing more debilitating than chronic back or joint pain. It can feel like a lifetime of misery.But researchers...

Legs of sprinters: Highly muscular, still maneuverable

A comprehensive knowledge of human biomechanics is useful for training athletes more effectively. From a biomechanical perspective, sprinting is challenging in comparison to walking...

Researchers discover key player in hepatitis A virus infection

The UNC School of Medicine lab of Stanley M. Lemon, MD, and colleagues used CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing to pinpoint a sugar-fatty acid molecule that...

Keeping web-like NETs from clogging blood vessels could improve stroke outcomes

Preventing the formation of a sticky, web-like substance that can form in blood vessels after a stroke could protect the brain and lead to...

Retinoic acid suppresses colorectal cancer development, Stanford study finds

Retinoic acid, a compound derived in the body from vitamin A, plays a critical role in suppressing colorectal cancer in mice and humans, according...

Study sheds light on fatty acid’s role in ‘chemobrain’ and multiple sclerosis

Researchers find lipids responsible for neural function are highly active and not inert as traditionally believedHOUSTON — Medical experts have always known myelin, the...

Bio-inspired lower-limb ‘wearing robotic exoskeleton’ for human gait rehab

WASHINGTON, D.C., Oct. 25, 2016 — Stroke and spinal cord injury patients often require gait rehabilitation to regain the ability to walk or to...

Interim open-label study results suggest higher dapivirine vaginal ring use, lower HIV risk

BOSTON (March 6, 2018) — Interim data from a large open-label study of the monthly dapivirine ring have found increased product use compared to...