Doctor calls on Australian government to lift threat of imprisonment from doctors

In The BMJ today, a doctor is calling on the Australian government to stop constraining doctors in the care of asylum seekers and refugees, and to adopt a humane stance to people seeking asylum.

David Berger, a doctor at Broome Hospital in Western Australia and a committee member of Doctors4Refugees, is making these calls following the high profile case at The Lady Cilento Hospital in Brisbane.

Paediatricians are refusing to discharge a baby facing deportation to a detention camp after the girl, a daughter of asylum seekers, suffered serious burns at an immigration camp on Nauru island. The Lady Cilento Hospital says the girl will not be released “until a suitable home environment is identified”.

Dr Berger explains that despite seeking to ensure the safety of their patient and doing nothing more than following their own ethical code, these doctors risk facing up to two years imprisonment under the 2015 Border Force Act.

Doctors have an ethical code since the time of the Hippocractic physicians nearly 2,500 years ago, he explains, yet this new law “compels them to follow the instructions of the Australian government, even if they believe this might be to the detriment of their patients.”

He says this case goes to the heart of the question of ‘duty of the physician’ versus ‘law of the land’, but argues that “compliance with the law can not inoculate the medical practitioner completely against the need to comply with their ethical code”.

He highlights the 2012 Derek Keilloh case in the UK that shows the “impossible ethical and legal position doctors now face in Australia…as they are caught between the profession’s ethical code, which places patient welfare at the heart of their endeavours, and the law of the country which places unacceptable obstacles in the way of doing so.”

Dr Berger adds that the actions of the Brisbane doctors “are not simply a piece of political grandstanding, but the courageous stand of professionals seeking to do the right thing by their patient and to live up to the standards of an ethical code by which they are morally and legally bound and which places patient welfare at its pinnacle.”

“They are behaving according to the very highest standards of their profession,” he adds, and calls on the government to repeal the relevant provisions of the Border Force Act and to adopt a “humane stance” towards people seeking asylum.


Media Contact

Gozde Zorlu
[email protected]

Efficiency of insect biodiversity monitoring via Malaise trap samples and DNA barcoding

The massive decline of over 75% insect biomass reported from Germany between 1989 and 2013 by expert citizen scientists proves the urgent need for...

Study shows high costs of fetal alcohol spectrum disorder

November 28, 2018 – Fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD) is a common condition with a high economic impact in both children and adults, concludes...

BU researcher receives prestigious Lucian Prize for contributions to cardiovascular science

(Boston)–Vasan Ramachandran, MD, FACC, the Jay and Louise Coffman Professor in Vascular Medicine at Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM), has been selected as...

Men and women have opposite genetic alterations in depression

Philadelphia, March 13, 2018 – Men and women with major depressive disorder (MDD) have opposite changes in the expression of the same genes, according...

ESMO Immuno-Oncology Congress: where the community of stakeholders meets

ESMO Immuno-Oncology Congress, Geneva, Switzerland, 13-16 December 2018LUGANO, 29 November 2018 – The European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO), (1) the leading professional organisation...

Swansea University collaboration promotes science education in Wales

Swansea University is collaborating with OXIS Energy UK Ltd. to support the development of enhanced lithium metal anodesSwansea University is collaborating with OXIS Energy...

MD Anderson and Astex Pharmaceuticals announce strategic collaboration to accelerate clinical evaluation of therapies for patients with leukemia

The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center and Astex Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Otsuka Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd., based in Tokyo,...

Black and Hispanic Californians face health discrimination; less trusting of clinicians

Black and Hispanic Californians face health care discrimination at higher rates and are less trusting of health care providersA recent statewide survey of Californians...

Study finds children with autism more likely to face maltreatment

A recent study by Vanderbilt researchers of 11 counties in Middle Tennessee revealed that children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) were nearly 2.5 times...